Critical Analysis and Reasoning Skills
It's not your
ability.
It's your
blind spots.
You get it down to two and lose the point anyway. Or you read every sentence with care and still run out of time. Either way, the explanation afterward usually makes sense. But knowing why you were wrong yesterday and noticing that you’re about to be wrong right now are two different skills.
Dissecting Inference
Answer Choices
An answer choice can repeat the passage’s own words and still make a claim the passage does not support. Here, we examine two choices word by word to explain why one must be eliminated and why the other is correct.
The passage suggests which of the following about the adoption of a standard pitch?
Instrument makers
standardization
to protect their existing inventories.
In the passagea national standard would render that stock unsellable overnight
The passage gives the makers a reason to object. It never says they actually opposed standardization.
Either unsupported claim is enough to eliminate this choice.
A technical solution can be available for some time before the conditions for its adoption exist.
In the passage“the physicists supplied the decisive measurements”
In the passage“the compensation schemes negotiated with the trade”
The technical solution existed before the financial arrangements that allowed it to be adopted.
Different wording preserves the relationship in the passage.
Read the full passage paragraph
Before the nineteenth century, no two orchestras in Europe tuned alike. A visiting soloist arriving in Vienna found the ensemble pitched nearly a semitone above the one she had left in Paris, and singers complained, with some justice, that rising pitch was shortening careers. The reformers who eventually settled the question are usually described as having solved a technical problem, and the description is not wrong so far as it goes. But the foremost obstacle they faced was never acoustic. Instrument makers had built inventories to local pitches, and a national standard would render that stock unsellable overnight. Although the physicists supplied the decisive measurements, it was the compensation schemes negotiated with the trade, and not the measurements, that moved the standard from proposal to law.
Why we pick wrong answers
The inference example shows how familiar language can win your trust before you have checked the claim. The book examines 24 biases and patterns that can lead to errors throughout your work.
The method, from planning to review
Plan how to use the section’s time. Build a map while you read. Research the question, examine the answer choices, and review the reasoning behind each miss. The examples below introduce that work.
Topic: the new subject matter a paragraph brings.
Role: what the author is doing with the paragraph, such as conceding, contrasting or giving an example.
Noteboard: the wet-erase booklet you get at the test center.
Trait words: words naming a characteristic of the paragraph's topic. Strung together, they add up to the paragraph's point.
Prioritizing language: words that put one thing ahead of another, such as first, primary or foremost.
Before the section
Passage planUse full-section practice to compare passage plans by total right answers. The book explains how to choose a plan and manage the time while keeping the method intact.
Compare total right answers.
The read
The map“Your map is every note you take and every mark you make as you read.”
From the book
But the foremost obstacle they faced was never acoustic. Instrument makers had built inventories to local pitches…
corrects usual acct of
pitch standardization
This excerpt shows part of the map, not the complete note-taking process.
Explore the mapThe question
Research & pre-phrasePre-phrase: your own answer, built from your research before you look at the choices.
The question determines what you research and how you use it. The book distinguishes retrieval from inference, and teaches the research and pre-phrase appropriate to each question type.
The passage suggests which of the following about the adoption of a standard pitch?
“…the compensation schemes negotiated with the trade, and not the measurements, that moved the standard from proposal to law.”
The answer choices
Two read-throughsThe book separates the first read-through from the closer work on surviving choices. It teaches you to explain an elimination in words, while keeping retrieval and inference distinct.
Instrument makers opposed standardization primarily to protect their existing inventories.
The passage does not say the makers opposed standardization.
It does not rank their motives.
After the section
Your chartA wrong answer does not tell you how the error happened. Reconstruct your own reasoning, locate where it went wrong, and write a prevention you can use on a later question.
Why I got it wrong
“I didn’t like B because it read like nothing I had highlighted.”Passage One · Question 2
Prevention
“When two survive and one uses the passage’s own nouns, translate the other back into the passage’s words before deciding.”Opening of this row’s prevention
INK FORMS RIVERSMCAT CARSThe Specialist’s
Approach
The complete method, with 20 original passages and every answer explained.
- Teaching
- 6 passages
- Drill
- 8 passages
- Exam
- 6 passages
The Free Error Check
The book describes about fifteen minutes of questions built around its biases and patterns. Explore one example and see what a selected answer can and cannot tell you about your reasoning.
Full check in preparation
Explore the previewBook & passage updates.
News from MCAT CARS.